Our Menu

12 permanent flavors are virtually always available. They include Trailer Trash, Professor, Oatmeal Raisin in the Sun, Strawberry, Chocolate, Vanilla, Butterfinger, C is for Cookie, Movie Star, Some Like It Hot, and Peanut, Peanut Butter and Chocolate.

We regularly post our new flavors on Facebook and Twitter, so follow us for current flavor offerings or call the store for today's selection.

See one you MUST have? We make custom flavors for qunatities as small as five pints. Call our store to discuss your options.

Ice cream flavor list (so far...)
3 Alive
A La Mode Is Overrated -- Apple Pie ice cream
A Salt & Buttery -- Vanilla with chocolate covered pretzels and a peanut butter swirl
A Whopper of an Ice Cream -- Vanilla with crushed Whoppers
Ambrosia -- Vanilla with mandarin oranges, pineapple, coconut, pecans, cherries, and marshmallows
America's Da Bomb Pop -- red, white, and blue sherbet
Appelicious! -- Apple Cider Sorbet
Are You There God? It's Me, Margarita -- Key Lime Sherbet
Aroma-therapy -- Honey ice cream with an infusion of lavender
Artist Formerly Known As Mints -- Chocolate Mint ice cream with chopped peppermint patty pieces
Avid Avacodo -- Avocado ice cream
Avocado Lime
Banana Fanna Fo Fudding -- Banana Pudding Ice cream (with Vanilla Wafers, of course)
Bananas Foster
Basil Strawberry Lemon Sorbet
Basil Tomatillo Overdrive -- basil-infused ice cream with a tomatillo sauce swirl
Batter Up! -- Brownie Batter ice cream with brownie chunks and walnuts
Black Walnut
Blind Melon -- Cantaloupe and Honey Dew melon sherbet
Blutopia -- Blueberry Cheesecake
Blueberry Lemon
Blueberry Muffin
Blueberry Muffin Sherbet
Brach's Obama -- Vanilla and Chocolate swirl with maple nuts and Brach’s caramel pieces
Brilliant! It's Guinness -- Guinness-infused ice cream
Butterscotch
Butterscotch Turtle Cheesecake
C-4 -- Caramel Chocolate Chip Cookie Explosion!
Campfire Cobbler -- Vanilla with a Peach-Raspberry cobbler swirl
4
Can't Elope Sorbet -- Cantelope sorbet (duh!)
The Cereal Killer -- Cinnamon Toast Crunch-infused soft-serve
The Cereal Killer 2.0 -- Froot Loops-infused soft-serve
Chai Curious -- Spiced Chai Tea
Charmed, I’m Sure -- Vanilla with White Chocolate Lucky Charms pieces
Cherr-Aid -- Cherry Sorbet
Cherry Pomegranate Sorbet
Cherry Springer -- Amaretto Chocolate Ice Cream with smoked almonds, cherries, and brownies
Chocoholics Anonymous -- Chocolate ice cream with dark, white, and semi-sweet chocolate pieces, Hershey kisses and chocolate chip cookie dough
Chocolate Almond Brother's Band -- Chocolate with almond slices
Chocolate Cheesecake
Chocolate Chip
Chocolate Cocount Curry
Chocolate Curry
Commit-mint Phobe -- Peppermint with crushed Oreo pieces
Chocolate Peppermint Soy
Chocolate Sorbet
Coffee Sorbet
Cookie's Fortune -- Chocolate with chocolate chip cookie pieces
Cop Stop -- Coffee ice cream with assorted donut pieces
Cranberry Sorbet
Cranberry Grape Sorbet
CuppaHumanKindness -- Mocha ice cream with a Nutella swirl
Do You Know The Muffin Man? -- Vanilla ice cream with blueberry muffin pieces
Do You Like Pina Colada? -- Coconut ice cream with pineapple bits (non-alcoholic for the kiddies!)
Doh! -- Vanilla with Cookie Dough bits
Doh-Re-Mi -- Vanilla with cookie dough bits, honey roasted peanuts, and peanut butter chips
Duff N/A -- Root Beer Float
East Academy Tornado -- Blue Raspberry with a Lime Sherbet Swirl
Egg Nog
Eh, What's Up Doc? -- Carrot Cake
ELM -- a red and gray swirled vanilla for East Literature Magnet School
Electric Bluegaloo
The Evil Professor -- Chocolate Coconut ice cream with almonds, cashews, and pecans
Fruit Ole! -- Pineapple Cilantro
From Prussia With Love -- German Chocolate cake
Funny Farm -- Vanilla with iced animal crackers
Get Lucky! -- Mint Chocolate Chip with Lucky Charms Marshmallows
Gingerbread Man -- Gingerbread ice cream
Handlebar Pistachio -- Pistachio-flavored ice cream with pistachio pieces
Grapefruit Mint Sorbet
Guava Banana Sorbet
Hello, I Am Mango! -- Mango sorbet
Happy Trails To You -- Honey-infused vanilla with trail mix pieces
Happy Trails To You, Too -- Rum-infused vanilla with trail mix pieces
How Do You Like Them Apples? -- Apple Cinnamon chessecake ice cream
How Much Is That Doggie Ice Cream In The Window? -- Vanilla with oatmeal and honey. This flavor’s for the dogs…literally!
I Can't Believe It's Not Butterfinger -- Vanilla with crushed Butterfinger
I Yam What I Yam -- Sweet potato ice cream with marshmallows
I'm Soy Excited -- Soy Vanilla
The Ice Cream Is Bananas…B-A-N-A-N-A-S! -- Banana ice cream with chocolate chip cookies and a peanut butter swirl
The Ice Cream Formerly Known As Mints -- Chocolate Mint Ice Cream with Peppermint Patties
Inside Out -- Peanut Butter ice cream with a fudge swirl
Isle of Malta -- Chocolate Malt
It's Not Easy Being Green Tea -- Green Tea ice cream
It’s Rumbelievable! -- Rum Raisin ice cream
It's Still Rocky Road To Me -- Rocky Road ice cream
Jackfruit Sherbet
Jamaica Me Crazy! -- Hibiscus ice cream
Kiwi
Krispee-Kreme Donut
Lady Goo-Goo -- Chocolate with chopped Goo-Goo clusters, marshmallows, and pecans
Lemon Pound Cake
Lickory Dickory Dock -- Licorice ice cream
Life Is A Cabernet -- Pear Sorbet with a Cabernet reduction
Little Debbie Does Ice Cream -- Vanilla with swiss cake rolls and a fudge swirl
Lime In The Coconut -- Vegan Coconut with lime juice
Love Is A Butterfield -- Butter Pecan
Mad Donna's Mole Orange Habenero -- Chocolate ice cream with mole paste and orange habenero sauce
Mango Blueberry Sorbet
Maple Nutty Yum-Yum -- No Sugar Added Maple Walnut
The Marion Berry -- Blackberry Sorbet
The Mary Anne -- No Sugar Added Vanilla
The Mary Anne 2.0 -- No Sugar Added Vanilla with a Chocolate swirl
Minty Python -- Peppermint-flavored ice cream with semi-sweet chocolate chips
Minty Python 2.0 -- Chocolate Peppermint-flavored ice cream with semi-sweet chocolate chips
Mocha Chocalatta Ya Ya -- Coffee ice cream with brownie chunks
Mocha-leckka-hi-mekka-hiney-ho
Movie Star -- Lemon Ginger Custard
My Cherry Amor -- Amaretto-infused ice cream with cherry cordials
Nanna Nutter Butter -- Banana ice cream with Nutter Butter pieces
Nilla Nutter Butter -- Vanilla with Nutter Butter pieces
No Sugar Added Apple Pie
No Sugar Added Butter Pecan
Oatmeal Raisin In The Sun -- Cinnamon ice cream with oatmeal raisin cookies
Oh Soy! -- Pumpkin Soy ice cream
Ol’ Glory -- Red, White, and Blue swirled Vanilla
Orange Banana Sherbet
Orange Blossom Special -- Vanilla with Orange Extract-reminiscent of a Creamsicle
Orange Curry Sorbet
Orange You Glad I Didn't Say Banana? -- Orange Sherbet
Orange You Glad I Didn’t Say Pineapple? -- Orange Pineapple Sorbet
Orenthal James Sherbet -- Orange Juice Sorbet
Oreo Speedwagon -- Mocha ice cream with Crushed Oreos
Peachy Keen -- Peach Sorbet
Peanut Butter And Jelly -- Peanut Butter ice cream with strawberry jelly
Peanut Butter Cookie Explosion -- Vanilla with peanut butter cookie pieces
Peanut, Peanut Butter. . .And Chocolate -- Chocolate ice cream with a peanut butter swirl
Pearis Hilton -- Pear Sorbet with a Riesling reduction
Pecan -- Vanilla with whole pecans
Peppermint Patty LaBelle -- Peppermint ice cream with York Peppermint Patty slices
Peter Peter Pumpkin Eater -- Pumpkin Pie ice cream
Pineapple Basil Sorbet
Pineapple Express -- Pineapple Sorbet with chipotle pepper
Please Cheese Me! -- Cheesecake Ice Cream with graham cracker crust
Please, Don’t Be So Melon-dramatic -- Cucumber Melon Sorbet
Plum & Quints Sorbet
Plum Orange Sorbet
Pom Queen -- Pomegranate Sorbet
Pomegranate Blueberry Sorbet
Pomegranate Cranberry Sorbet
Pomegranate Sherbet
Pralines & Cream
The Professor -- Coconut flavored ice cream with pecans, almonds, and cashews
Raspberry Cheesecake (No Sugar Added)
Raspberry Sorbet
Rather Sherber -- Raspberry Sherbet
Red Bean
Red Velvet Elvis -- Red Velvet cake ice cream with a cream cheese icing swirl
Reese's Cup -- Vanilla ice cream with chopped Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup pieces
Robert Broulet -- Butterscotch ice cream with Crème Brulee candied almonds
Rosewater
Rosewater Pistachio Saffron -- Rosewater with saffron spice and pistachio pieces
Rum Peanut Yum! -- Rum ice cream with Vanilla Rum Candied Peanuts
S.W.A. (Snickers With Attitude) -- Vanilla with Snickers Dark candy slices
Say Was? -- Wasabi ice cream
She's My Cherry Pie -- Vanilla with cherry pie filling and pie crust pieces
Smore Than A Feeling -- Chocolate with marshmallows and graham cracker pieces
Smurfberry Crunch -- Blue Raspberry sherbet with Nerds candy
Snow Cream
Some Like It Hot -- Chocolate with cinnamon and cayenne pepper
Someday My Mints Will Come -- Peppermint ice cream with peppermint slivers
Somewhere Over The Rainbow Sherbet
Sour Cherry Cheesecake
Spongebob's House -- Pineapple Sherbet
Strawberry Balsamic Sorbet
Strawberry Banana Sorbet
Strawberry Cheesecake
Strawberry Fields Forever -- Strawberry ice cream
Strawberry Ginger Ale Sorbet
Strawberry Lemonade Sorbet
Strawberry Sorbet
Sun Drop Sorbet
Sweet Berry -- Vanilla ice cream with blackberries, raspberries, and blueberries
Take Me Out To The Ballgame -- Popcorn flavored ice cream with Crunch-n-Munch
Thankth Eather Bunny -- Malted Vanilla with Robin’s Eggs candy pieces
Thingamajig -- Vanilla with Whatchamallcallit pieces
The Big Cheesy
The Heath Is On -- Vanilla with crushed Heath bars
There's Nutellin -- Chocolate with a Nutella swirl
They're Grrrrrrrrrrape! -- Grape sorbet
Toffee Loaded Coffee -- Coffee ice cream with crushed Heath candy
Tomato Orange Cardamon -- Tomato Orange sorbet with Cardamon spice
Tomato Strawberry Sorbet
Trailer Trash -- Vanilla with Oreo, Twix, Butterfinger, Nestle Crunch, Snickers, M&Ms, and Reese’s Pieces
Trailer Trash 2.0 -- Same as Trailer Trash, only in CHOCOLATE!
Trailer Trash w/ Cheese Curls -- Same as Trailer Trash, as well as Cheese Curls
Turtle Cheesecake
Vegan Coconut
Vanilla Ice Ice Baby -- Vanilla Ice Cream
War And Peach -- Peach ice cream
Watermelon Sorbet
Wehadababyitsaboy -- Birthday Cake ice cream with Rainbow Sprinkles and blue icing, in honor of Glancy, heir to the Pied Piper Empire
We're Hammond It Up! -- Apple Pie Ice Cream with Hammonds candied black walnuts
Who Wants To Be A Thousandaire? -- Vanilla with 100 Grand pieces
You Say It's Your Burfday Cake -- Birthday Cake ice cream with rainbow sprinkles and strawberry icing
You're Nutty Buddy -- Vanilla with a fudge swirl, chopped nut topping, and sugar cone pieces
You Were Mint For Me -- Peppermint ice cream with white chocolate peppermint pieces